Saturday, September 19, 2009


A couple of decades ago I got ahold of High Weirdness by Mail and made a hobby of collecting crank literature from variety of religious and political nutjobs. I viewed this as a form of research. Seeing the odd pathways it is possble for human minds to go down was a way to understand the workings of more ordinary ones. My former housemate Donna Kossy made a small career out of similar activities.

The Internet of course has made it too easy to find disturbed and disturbing people, so it became somewhat less interesting to me. Also there was an element of it I found distasteful, as if I was mocking the patients in Bedlam as was the practice in 18th century. So I mostly dropped that hobby. Kookdom, I supposed, would continue as ever on the fringes of discourse, perhaps gaining some strengths from the net's ability to let interest groups coalesce.

I never expected the nutjob paranoid style -- the kind that likes to draw elaborate influence diagrams -- to become mainstream. Yet here is Glenn Beck, owner of a show on a mainstream corporate network and Time magazine cover subject, ranting away about some conspiracy involving Che, Woodrow Wilson, George Soros, and of course Obama.

I don't really believe that Beck is a genuine kook (although who knows about his audience). He is a showman, and has cleverly appropriated the style of paranoid conspiracy theorists for his own purposes. Note that whereas the genuine paranoids would at least pick targets for their diagrams that had some actual power (The Trilateral Commission, Bilderbergs, Rothschilds, etc), Beck targets organizations like ACORN and the SEIU which are composed largely of poor and working-class people. This cleverly redirects whatever genuine insights the conspiracy-mongers have to offer. There is, in fact, an elite who runs the world, whether they need to meet in shadowy rooms to do it or not. They do not have your interests at heart. This fact drives some people mad, but at least their madness is grounded in something real. The madness of Beck and his followers lacks that. It's either insincere or just plain stupid. It's paranoia for lazy obese Americans who can't even manage to generate their own crazy obsessions.

Beck's success at peddling a faux version of kookery just proves once again that the genius of America is its ability to convert absolutely anything into a product.


TGGP said...

Sounds like you bought into Michel Foucault's bullshit on Bedlam.

I was personally nauseated by the idiocy I saw when Beck was on CNN (I don't get Fox). Bob Murphy claims that Beck actually goes after big corporations, but I don't see what populist gropings can make up for his prior bad acts.

mtraven said...

Foucault didn't make that up; it's depicted in Hogarth's paintings. Which doesn't make it necessarily true, of course.

Glenn Beck himself is not very interesting; that he is gaining a mass following seems significant though.

David Xavier said...

"Glenn Beck himself is not very interesting; that he is gaining a mass following seems significant though"

And what of the "hating Glen Beck" movement ... madness about the madness,huh. I think you need to re-examine Foucault if you think that organisations as problematic as Acorn have no power. You talk of shadowy elites running the world , is not Obama or Soros etc elite? Surely we should question whether the "remaking" of society is in our interests or is an ideological 'will to power' that promises "heaven" but merely replaces one hierarchy with another ...but leaves Americans substantially worse off?

Acorn receives federally funding , it should be scruntinised , shine a little light I say.

Anonymous said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.